Did the Bologna Process Challenge the German Apprenticeship System? Evidence from a Natural Experiment

Download statistics - Document (COUNTER):

Thomsen, S.L.; Trunzer, J.: Did the Bologna Process Challenge the German Apprenticeship System? Evidence from a Natural Experiment. Hannover : Institutionelles Repositorium der Leibniz Universität Hannover, 2020 (LCSS Working Papers ; 5), 34 S. DOI: https://doi.org/10.15488/10148

Selected time period:


Sum total of downloads: 270

Starting in 1999, the Bologna Process reformed the German five-year study system for a first degree into the three-year bachelor’s (BA) system to harmonize study lengths in Europe and improve competitiveness. This reform unintentionally challenged the German apprenticeship system that offers three-year professional training for the majority of school leavers. Approximately 29% of new apprentices are university-eligible graduates from academic-track schools. We evaluate the effects of the Bologna reform on new highly educated apprentices using a generalized difference-in-differences design based on detailed administrative student and labor market data. Our estimates show that the average regional expansion in first-year BA students decreased the number of new highly educated apprentices by 3%–5%; average treatment effects on those indecisive at school graduation range between –18% and –29%. We reveal substantial gender and occupational heterogeneity: males in STEM apprenticeships experienced the strongest negative effects. The reform aggravated the skills shortage in the economy.
License of this version: CC BY 3.0 DE
Document Type: Report
Publishing status: publishedVersion
Issue Date: 2020
Appears in Collections:LCSS Working Papers : Schriftenreihe Leibniz Center for Science and Society

distribution of downloads over the selected time period:

downloads by country:

pos. country downloads
total perc.
1 image of flag of Germany Germany 170 62.96%
2 image of flag of United States United States 34 12.59%
3 image of flag of No geo information available No geo information available 18 6.67%
4 image of flag of China China 6 2.22%
5 image of flag of Russian Federation Russian Federation 5 1.85%
6 image of flag of Czech Republic Czech Republic 4 1.48%
7 image of flag of Sweden Sweden 3 1.11%
8 image of flag of France France 3 1.11%
9 image of flag of Italy Italy 2 0.74%
10 image of flag of Brazil Brazil 2 0.74%
    other countries 23 8.52%

Further download figures and rankings:


Zur Erhebung der Downloadstatistiken kommen entsprechend dem „COUNTER Code of Practice for e-Resources“ international anerkannte Regeln und Normen zur Anwendung. COUNTER ist eine internationale Non-Profit-Organisation, in der Bibliotheksverbände, Datenbankanbieter und Verlage gemeinsam an Standards zur Erhebung, Speicherung und Verarbeitung von Nutzungsdaten elektronischer Ressourcen arbeiten, welche so Objektivität und Vergleichbarkeit gewährleisten sollen. Es werden hierbei ausschließlich Zugriffe auf die entsprechenden Volltexte ausgewertet, keine Aufrufe der Website an sich.

Search the repository